Receiver’s Settlement of Companies’ Derivative Claims Against One Owner Unwound on Due Process Grounds
Receivers have been covered in many prior posts, both here and on the Money and Dirt blog. For examples, see here, here, here, and here.
Some receivers, like those appointed to safeguard real property security pursuant to a deed of trust, are relatively easy to get appointed and have limited powers. Other receivers, like those appointed to take control of a business entity under a court’s general equity powers, are more difficult to get appointed and have much broader powers. But their power is not unlimited.
An opinion recently filed by California’s First Appellate District — Hale v. Drysdale — illustrates the point. The Hale opinion is unpublished and therefore not binding precedent, but it still provides a useful guidepost.
Facts: court appoints receiver in partner dispute; receiver enters into settlement of companies’ derivative claims
Chris Hale and Ray Drysdale were “former business partners turned litigation adversaries.”
In 2018, they formed several companies to market and distribute commercial agricultural products. At some point, Hale accused Drysdale of planning to seize control of the business and embezzling funds to a new corporate account. Hale sued Drysdale, and Drysdale filed a cross-claim against Hale, alleging it was Hale who embezzled funds from the companies.
The trial court appointed a receiver, holding neither party should be running the companies during the litigation. The receiver told the parties that he would wind up the companies as they were insolvent and unable to continue operating.
Meanwhile, Drysdale filed a new, separate action against Hale and others, alleging that Hale had sold some of the companies’ assets to newly created entities that he controlled and had misappropriated other assets. The court in that action ruled early that the claims were derivative in nature — i.e., they belonged to the companies, and only the receiver in the original action had standing to pursue them.
Trial court: settlement approved after in camera review of financial information
The receiver ultimately entered into a settlement of the companies’ derivative claims against Hale and filed a motion seeking the trial court’s approval of the settlement. Under the proposed settlement, Hale and associated individuals and entities would pay the companies $227,000 for the companies’ release of claims against them. The proposed settlement payment had been almost twice that amount in an earlier proposed settlement, but the receiver concluded that a reduction was warranted because “it would be difficult and costly to collect a substantial judgment from the Hales and associated entities.”
The receiver explained that he had reviewed “documents concerning the Hales’ finances” and proposed that the trial court should review the financial information in camera — i.e., privately in the judge’s chambers without the other side seeing. Drysdale’s attorney objected to the proposed in camera review.
After reviewing the financial information in camera, the trial court approved the receiver’s proposed settlement of the companies’ derivative claims against Hale.
Drysdale appealed.
Court of Appeal: reversed; in camera review violated due process
The Court of Appeal reversed, holding that the trial court’s process for reviewing the financial records in private (in camera) was procedurally flawed.
The court noted that general equity receivers are afforded wide discretion to accomplish their objectives, and review on appeal is confined to the deferential “abuse of discretion” standard. The court also observed that the proposed settlement was reasonable in the abstract: “we are inclined to agree with the Hales that the record evidence supports a finding that settling the derivative claims was necessary. … Evidence suggested that litigating these positions would be costly and collecting a large judgment would be unlikely.”
However, the trial court’s secretive in camera review of the financial records underlying its order approving the settlement tarnished the order and violated Drysdale’s due process rights: “Appellants claim the trial court violated their due process rights by considering documents concerning the Hales’ finances in camera, without allowing them or their counsel to review the documents. We agree[.]”
Under Evidence Code section 915, a trial court can review documents in camera to assist in deciding whether the documents are privileged and protected from disclosure. But section 915 does not authorize the court “to use that information to decide the merits of a case if the other side has not had an opportunity to review the material and be heard.”
Lesson
A receiver appointed by the court to take control of a business entity has broad powers to act on the entity’s behalf, but that power is not unlimited. Under the unpublished Hale opinion, the Court of Appeal reversed a trial court’s order approving a settlement where the trial court’s review of the financial documents underlying the settlement was only conducted in camera, and therefore violated due process.
* NOTE: The LLC Jungle will be moving to an upgraded back-end platform in December, so the next post might be delayed until January.